Showing posts with label it's my blog and I'll preach if I want to. Show all posts
Showing posts with label it's my blog and I'll preach if I want to. Show all posts

Saturday, September 3, 2011

The History of Homeschooling

I saw this at Ramblings of a Dysfunctional Homeschooler, and had to share it. It's a very interesting look at homeschooling statistics prepared by OnlineCollege.org.

Homeschooling

My comments, for what they're worth...

Does it seem a little silly to say that Alexander the Great is the first "known homeschooler?" What, did they eschew the local p.s. and send in an intent form? I don't know why, it just struck me as funny.

I've seen conflicting reports on test scores, including one study that found no measurable difference between the scores of homeschooled students and public school students.

This graphic includes "online education" under methodologies. In our state, students who use online schools are not technically counted as "homeschoolers" if the online school is public. So the numbers would be even higher if those students were included. (No matter how "schoolish" an online curriculum may be, those students are still getting a very different educational experience from students at brick-and-mortar schools!)

I really like the graphic showing why parents choose to homeschool. It's a good representation of what a complex decision it can be, and what a diverse group homeschooling families are.

Looking at the comparison section, I had to laugh. Not all schools can provide more resources than homeschoolers: there are plenty of schools out there who don't even have enough textbooks for their kids!

I'm completely confident that my kids have more resources than their public-schooled friends. Everything we have is used by two kids instead of a whole class. Our local school might have a more expensive microscope than ours, but ours works fine and it's available all the time. The same goes for our chemistry set, our computer, our binoculars, our math manipulatives, our art supplies, our book collection, and even the teacher! :) Plus, we can go to the library whenever we want, not just the first Monday of the month.

I can't say if our curriculum is richer than a public school's curriculum, because I don't know what the school kids are doing these days. But I can tell you that when my kids were in public school, they often seemed to touch briefly on a multitude of topics instead of studying anything in depth. My kids were vaguely familiar with historical events and scientific concepts, without having a real understanding of any of them. To me, a rich curriculum is measured in depth, not breadth.

Anyway, if you haven't seen this before, it's definitely worth a look!

Friday, August 19, 2011

Grown-Ups are Boring (Somewhat Rantish)

I stopped by the grocery store yesterday about 10 am, and noticed lots of moms and kids shopping together. A brief thought went through my mind: I guess this is the last time I'll see kids in here for a while.

That's an exaggeration. Of course there will be kids in the store after 3:45 pm, and on weekends. But by this time next week, the school-aged kids in my area will begin spending the majority of their time in a classroom, segregated from the rest of our community.

Boxwood PS kindergarten classroom
Soon to be filled!

Then the questions will begin for my family. Nearly every time my kids join me on an errand during regular school hours, someone asks us: Got the day off today?

Because it's just that unusual to see a child participating in daily life from approximately September 1 to May 31.


School bus invasion
Coming soon, to a neighborhood near you!

I feel sad for school kids, since most of them are not looking forward to going back to school.

But I feel sad for us grown-ups, too. Because our days are about to get a shade duller.

Have you ever noticed that an all-adult gathering is usually pretty boring? I guess that's not true at a scary movie or a comedy club, but when I go to the bank, the store, the library, or even out to lunch, and there are no kids to be seen, somehow the atmosphere is less lively, more somber.

Does this photo make you smile?

Board-Meeting

Does this one?

Face paint girls

The truth is, we need their energy, spontaneity, and creativity every bit as much as they need our guidance and protection.

Education is important. The future depends on the intellect and capability of the youngest generation. But in a perfect world, our kids wouldn't spend 180 days a year locked away from the world in order to learn about it.

Friday, July 8, 2011

Hooray for Summer Break!

Dog, cat and bird masks made from boxes and construction paper.

I listened to a very interesting program on the radio yesterday. Local teachers were discussing year-round schooling versus the traditional school calendar. The guests seemed to agree that students learn more and forget less when they attend year-round. One guest also suggested an increase in the usual 180 days spent in school each academic year.


Reading, reading, reading!

These teachers weren't unreasonable: they had observed how much kids forget during the summer and how much time is wasted reviewing skills that had already been mastered the previous year. Since teacher's livelihoods and reputations are judged on test scores these days, of course they would want to spend their time moving forward instead of reviewing last year's material.

The message seemed to be this: teachers enjoy the long summer break as much as anyone, and they know that kids look forward to their summers. BUT, the majority of kids don't do anything worthwhile over the summer. They just watch TV and play video games.


Tank battles on the street.

According to the teachers on the show, most kids don't travel, don't visit museums or libraries, and don't even read during summer break. And since their families are either unable or unwilling to make summer break into something beneficial for their kids, it's time to take a critical look at long summer breaks.

This made me so sad. Could I really be hearing this correctly? It seemed to me that the gist of the teachers' argument was that American families are so overwhelmed or so complacent that kids are actually better off spending most of their time at school.


German vocabulary labels.

Clearly, there are children out there who live in crisis situations and who might actually be better off at school. But these teachers weren't necessarily referring to the families who live on the brink of homelessness (or who may even be homeless) or the families who live in dangerous neighborhoods and who struggle to provide even the basics. No, they were talking about American families in general, from every rung of the socio-economic ladder. And they still felt that kids were better off at school.


Old MacDonald had a farm...

Ironically, I was listening to this radio show while cleaning and organizing our homeschool classroom. I looked around at all the books, art supplies, math manipulatives and science materials and I felt so grateful that we are able to provide these things to our kids. But of course, we haven't touched any of these supplies since the end of May. We haven't spent one minute doing "formal" schooling this summer.


Play? Did someone say play?

But we've still managed to learn every single day! Just off the top of my head, here are some activities we've enjoyed. I would count every one of these as a learning experience. As you can see, some were expensive and/or time-consuming. But many of them were free and easy!


Traditional German rhabarberkuchen.


1. Two road trips to visit relatives.

2. Practicing our German while entertaining our German friends. This has to be my favorite German word so far! (A friend said it sounds like what happens when you lose part of your swimsuit! Hee! Hee!)


3. Preparing and sampling traditional German food. You would not believe how good this pastry dough smelled...vanilla and sugar...mmm...


4. Picking up our CSA shares and learning about the farm that grew our vegetables. I made this quiche from CSA spinach, onions, and eggs!


5. Having a picnic in the mountains. I can't believe we had this spot all to ourselves on such a gorgeous day.


6. Taking care of our many pets. Here is Pumpkin, the newest member of the family. (And no, we didn't let him have the whole apple!)


7. Going to a Vietnamese restaurant and then exploring the nearby Asian supermarket. These coffee candies come from Thailand and they are sooooooo wonderful!


8. Messing around on the piano, letting the kids play whatever they want. Which is usually Axel F.

9. Taking our sick pug to the vet and looking at his chest x-ray. The FANTASTIC doctor could see that Super was interested, so he offered very detailed explanations and walked her through the entire x-ray.

11. Going to a cool museum exhibit and an IMAX movie.

12. Watching our garden grow and looking forward to our first harvest.


13. Making beautiful chalk art on the driveway.

14. Having a water pistol fight with friends: Dads against kids!


15. Making homemade lemonade. Experimenting with the recipe and trying to figure out which version would sell best at a future lemonade stand.

16. Karate lessons and practice.

17. Household chores like putting away laundry and doing dishes.

18. Sitting in the back yard watching the fluffy clouds turn into a storm front (and then getting the heck inside when the lightning started!)

19. Listening to rain, birds, and music.

20. Reading, reading, reading!

My kids are having very valuable experiences this summer. They would have to be doing some pretty amazing things at school to be better off spending their days in a classroom instead of at home.

I'm not sure what my point is here, except that it saddens me to think that so many kids don't get to experience the learning lifestyle, and instead see learning as a chore they have to do from September to May. Then they have earned the right to shut down their brains for three months!

And I feel bad for teachers, too. The teachers on the radio show were truly invested in helping their students learn better and retain more. I'm just not sure that more days in a classroom is really what kids need.